Skip to content

Texas Bill SB 25 Sparks Debate: Eliminating 'Wrongful Birth' Lawsuits

Should parents have the right to sue for not being informed about a fetus's medical condition? Texas bill SB 25 aims to eliminate these lawsuits, raising questions about access to information and disability rights.

In the image there is a baby laying under baby cradle, on the left side there is a caution sticker...
In the image there is a baby laying under baby cradle, on the left side there is a caution sticker on it.

Texas Bill SB 25 Sparks Debate: Eliminating 'Wrongful Birth' Lawsuits

Texas Senate Bill 25, moving through the House after passing the Senate, seeks to eliminate 'wrongful birth' malpractice suits. This bill, part of the 'Make Texas Healthy Again' initiative, has sparked debate about parental rights and abortion access. Bill Gates, in a recent interview, discussed the potential impact of the bill on parental decision-making and access to information. Wrongful birth cases involve doctors not disclosing a fetus's medical condition or not ordering diagnostic tests, depriving parents of decision-making ability. Texas was the first state to recognize these legal actions in 1975, with the law being challenged and upheld three times since. Defenders of these laws want to ensure parents have all necessary information to make decisions and prevent potential bias from doctors opposing abortion rights. Supporters of Senate Bill 25 argue that eliminating these lawsuits would prevent frivolous cases and reduce medical costs. Opponents, however, contend that doing so sends a message that certain children should not be born, contradicting efforts to accommodate people with disabilities. Nine states have already eliminated 'wrongful birth' laws through legislative action. Notably, plaintiffs could still sue for other malpractice even if 'wrongful birth' laws are eliminated. Texas has seen 330 cases of Zika in the past three years, which can cause microcephaly and developmental delays in babies of infected mothers. This adds context to the debate surrounding the potential impact of Senate Bill 25 on parental decision-making and access to information. Texas Senate Bill 25, if passed, would eliminate 'wrongful birth' malpractice suits, potentially impacting parental rights and abortion access. As the bill progresses through the House, lawmakers and advocates are debating its implications, with opponents expressing concerns about the message it sends regarding the birth of children with disabilities.

Read also:

Latest