Do tears provide falsehood? - There's commonly a tendency to take the word of weeping males more seriously. - Are emotions deceptive through tears?
A groundbreaking study published in the prestigious journal *PLOS One* has shed new light on the complexities of nonverbal emotional communication, particularly in the context of facial expressions involving tears. The research, which involved participants from Norway, Poland, South Africa, Canada, and the United Kingdom, reveals that the perceived sincerity of these expressions is influenced by various factors, including context, gender, and cultural expectations.
The study, conducted at the Polish University of Lodz, presented participants with images of faces, some of which had been manipulated to appear tearful. The participants were then asked to judge the honesty of the people in the photos. The results showed that tears had a relatively strong effect on photos of both men and women, particularly when they seemed less warm.
Interestingly, the study found that men's tears were perceived as more honest than women's tears, especially because men are culturally and socially less expected to cry. This unexpected behaviour signals stronger authenticity to observers. Similarly, the perceived warmth of the person crying also affected credibility. Individuals perceived as less warm gained more perceived honesty when crying compared to those perceived as warm.
The study also highlighted the role of cultural context in these perceptions. Though the research emphasizes widespread patterns, it acknowledges that cultural norms about emotion expression influence how sincerity is judged.
The study also considered situations where people were behaving manipulatively, such as trying to cut in line, and found that tears had a relatively stronger effect in non-manipulative situations. Tears were also found to have only a small overall influence on how participants perceived honesty in the photos.
The research also suggests that tears might be socially beneficial for men and less warm individuals, as they are more likely to be believed. However, the study did not investigate other factors that might have influenced the perception of honesty in the non-tearful photos.
In summary, the study suggests that facial expressions of sorrow or sadness via tears are not universally perceived as honest or sincere but are judged based on who is crying, under what circumstances, and cultural expectations related to gender and warmth. This nuanced view advances understanding of nonverbal emotional communication across diverse cultural settings.
[1] Study reference [2] Study reference [3] Study reference
- It's advantageous for men and less warm individuals to display tears in a community setting as their sincerity is perceived more often, potentially due to established societal norms and expectations, as evidenced by the study published in PLOS One.
- The science of nonverbal emotional communication can greatly benefit from interdisciplinary research, considering factors like health-and-wellness, mental-health, and diverse cultural contexts, as demonstrated by the groundbreaking study conducted at the Polish University of Lodz.
